Friday, May 24, 2024

Why This Flower Expert Says Ditch the Roses and Go Local Instead


Do you know what goes into that bouquet of roses? Chances are they’re not local flowers, and they’re coming with a big carbon footprint.

Emily Boschetto co-founded Matilda’s Bloombox nearly a decade ago in her San Francisco garage along with her husband Matt. His family had a history of flower farming, and the couple was motivated to find a way to support local farmers and sell more flowers from regional growers. “At that time we would build the boxes at night when the kids were asleep and then our deliveries would start at 3 am,” Boschetto tells Ethos.

She says the business was steadily growing, but then the pandemic hit. The small garage operation was now delivering more than a thousand flower boxes a week — some as get-well gestures, others as thank yous, and for other orders, it was simply a way to brighten the mood while isolating at home. And, critically, it was a way to support local farmers and help bring flowers into the locally grown conversation.

The cut flower market

There’s more to flower bouquets than just buoyed spirits. Most flowers are flown into the U.S. from Colombia, the leading exporter to the U.S. for cut flowers. It complicates the market for local growers and leaves a carbon footprint as big as, if not more so, than much of our food. The cut flower market is huge — globally it’s expected to reach $41 billion by 2027; in the U.S., it’s expected to grow from $34 million in 2019 to more than $49 million in 2028.

Photo courtesy Sindy Strife

Colombia’s flower production — a byproduct of effective crackdowns on cocaine exports — has taken a toll on U.S. growers; in the last three decades, U.S. production of roses dropped about 95 percent, down from 545 million a year to fewer than 30 million.

According to The Washington Post, hundreds of cargo planes full of flowers fly from the Andes to Miami in the month before Valentine’s Day. In the three weeks leading up to Valentine’s Day alone, 30 cargo jets fly from Colombia to Miami every single day as does a similar amount from Ecuador. This amounts to more than 15,000 tons of flowers delivered in less than thirty days. It’s the same for Mother’s Day, too. It’s estimated that Americans will spend around $3 billion on flowers for moms this year.

carbon footprint of roses
Courtesy Polina Kholodova

Experts say it’s difficult to estimate the exact carbon footprint of roses, but 100 million roses — the average number sold in the U.S. on Valentine’s Day or Mother’s Day — are estimated to produce about 9,000 metric tons of carbon dioxide. According to the EPA’s emissions calculator, that’s the equivalent of driving more than 22 million miles.

“At a global level, you often find the high volume flowers, like alstroemeria, lilies, solidago, spray roses for instance, are the flowers that are sold in the large supermarkets because these are the only flowers you can only grow in big, colossal volumes,” Boschetto says. These bigger operations in other countries can rely heavily on chemicals, some of which aren’t allowed in the U.S. Boschetto says there’s good reason to look local.

Locally-grown flowers

Flowers are grown across the U.S., she says, but California is the biggest flower state. “The climate here is perfect because it’s so varied. Our protea grower, for instance — his protea plants were planted here almost 40 years ago, and initially from South Africa. The climate on the coastline in California is very similar to South Africa; mountainous, microclimate, lots of wind to keep the temperatures slightly cooler, lots of sand and rock. It’s incredible the variety of landscape you find in California,” she says.

But as the global flower trade puts a damper on U.S. demand, Boschetto says many farmers are selling out to the booming cannabis industry. “It’s a hard life growing flowers, especially when the environment changes so rapidly, wildfire risk, drought, Covid, you name it, our farmers have seen it,” she says.

flower shop
Photo courtesy John Flygare

Many of the flower farmers Matilda’s sources from also grow fruits and vegetables, “rotating the soil is extremely important,” Boschetto says. “Certain flowers require different nutrients. I know our farmers in San Diego grow lemons, kumquats, kale, and avocados. Growing flowers, just like growing fruit and vegetables, is the salt of the earth of life.”  

And while the local flower industry is still years away from rivaling the imports, Boschetto is inspired by the movement to support local. Matilda’s Bloombox is a supporter of the California Flowers Association. “I love the campaign they are doing at the moment about flowers bringing mindfulness and joy into your life. Personally, I’ve never known anyone to receive a box of flowers and not smile. It’s the small joy in our lives that just makes life better,” she says.

The bigger point though, Boschetto says, is that there is beauty in small-volume farmers. “In the same way that food tastes better when it’s not mass-produced, flowers smell better, they look better and they last longer. That’s the beauty that we’re trying to share.”

Sustainable home decor houseplants
Houseplants make lovely replacements for imported flowers. | Photo courtesy Priscilla DuPreez

And to the question every florist hears this time of year: roses or something else? Boschetto recommends going in the opposite direction and finding flowers that are more interesting than roses. And of course, she says, do what you can to go local. “I’m not a red roses kind of girl,” she says. “This year we’ve secured a limited amount of Empress Protea and they are fabulous.”

There’s another alternative, too: houseplants. When properly cared for, they can last years — decades, even — and they provide a local, sustainable alternative to imported cut flowers.

Related on Ethos:


Vegan Shakshuka From the BOSH! Kitchen

From BOSH! on a Budget, a super tasty and simple vegan shakshuka recipe for a breakfast or weekend brunch.

It’s Time to Declutter: the 5-Step Checklist

Turns out how to declutter your home responsibly is a lesson in how to be more sustainable all around. And this checklist will help.

Is Temu Ethical? Here’s Why You Should Be Wary of the Bargain App

With its cheap and extensive range of consumer goods, including fast fashion, Temu seems like the ultimate overnight success. But is it all too good to be true? Spoiler alert: probably, yes. 

Natural and Non-Toxic Cleaning Products for a Spotless, Stress-Free Home

For a natural, non-toxic clean home, shop these brands' sustainable cleaning products for every room of the house.

Coconut MCT Oil: It May Be the Wellness Secret You Need

MCT coconut oil wellness products have skyrocketed in popularity...