Sunday, March 3, 2024

Hydrogen Cars Are More Sustainable Than EVs. So Why Aren’t There More of Them?


Hydrogen fuel cell technology offers numerous benefits, according to proponents of the technology. So why hasn’t it made more of an impact when it comes to cars?

Hydrogen is the universe’s most abundant element, and when burned, the only emission it generates is water vapor. So given the scrutiny faced by the motoring industry amid climate breakdown fears, surely it would make sense to turn to hydrogen to power our vehicles. So why hasn’t that happened at scale yet?

While commercial hydrogen fuel cell electric vehicles (FCEVs) are available in the UK and US among other nations, they have not caught on in the same way electric vehicles have.

According to recent Hydrogen Fuel Cell Partnership data, 2022 saw a 19 percent decline in new hydrogen fuel cell car sales.

Despite the declining numbers, the cars certainly have sustainability appeal: Hyundai described the vehicles as ‘the ultimate eco-cars, offering long cruising ranges with a short refueling time and generating zero emissions’ in a press release announcing the launch of its second-generation hydrogen-powered Mirai in 2020 (the first hit the market in 2014).

Honda just announced that it will start U.S. production of hydrogen cars in 2024.

“Honda established our goal to realize carbon neutrality by 2050 and the complete electrification of our vehicle lineup by 2040 is critical to achieving it,” said Gary Robinson, vice president of Auto Planning & Strategy for American Honda Motor Co., Inc. “As we accelerate our plan to produce Honda battery EVs in the United States, we also will begin low volume production of fuel cell electric vehicles there to further explore their great potential as part of a sustainable transportation future.”

Courtesy Hyundai

Few FCEVs are currently offered to consumers: in the U.K., there is the Hyundai Nexo (which retails for £69,495 apiece, with 28 reportedly sold), and the Toyota Mirai, with a £55,000+ price tag and around 200 sales. Other motoring manufacturers including BMW, Land Rover, and Vauxhall are reportedly planning to release their own hydrogen-powered cars within the next five years.

When it comes to the States, the Hyundai Nexo ($58,935) and the Toyota Mirai ($49,500) are both available, alongside the Hyundai Clarity Fuel Cell ($58,490).

Few FCEVs seem to be operational in the US, with a lack of infrastructure cited as a reason by Autoweek, which says ‘almost all America’s fuel cell vehicles are in California. There are a handful in Hawaii’.

This is because outside of California’s 48 Hydrogen Refuelling Stations (HRS), and Hawaii’s one, there is currently no hydrogen fueling network anywhere else in the States, though there are some in development in the North East.

Hydrogen infrastructure

Infrastructure issues are also in factor in the limited number of FCEVs on U.K. roads, according to lobby group UKH2Mobility, an industry-led forum that ‘facilitates regular dialog with U.K. Government and other public sector stakeholders, about the future strategic direction for hydrogen mobility in the UK’.

It says there are only 11 HRS currently in operation around the U.K., with the majority clustered in the South West, near London. However, it believes the infrastructure is worth developing.

The organization’s website states: “Developing and bringing any major new technology to the commercial market costs money, and hydrogen is no different. 

“However, hydrogen has a key role to play in the future decarbonisation of the transport sector because it offers three significant benefits to the UK and to the wider, global economy.”

Courtesy Toyota

The first benefit it lists is energy security, due to hydrogen’s wide availability. Secondly, it notes that FCEVs offer environmental improvement by decarbonising the transport sector, which it says will ‘reduce emissions, limit the impact of potentially damaging climate change and improve human health well into the future’.

Explaining why hydrogen is so environmentally friendly, it notes that hydrogen can be produced from any form of primary energy, renewable or conventional. 

“As a fuel it is widely available, efficient, renewable and non-polluting,” it says.

“Today, the majority of hydrogen is produced from steam reforming. However, an increasing number of plants are using renewable electricity to drive electrolysis which is totally renewable.”

It adds that even when hydrogen is produced from fossil fuels, it can ‘significantly reduce the overall amount of greenhouse gases and pollutants produced in power generation plants’.

On top of energy security and environmental benefits, the third upside of developing a new hydrogen-based transport sector ‘would provide the opportunity to create new businesses, new jobs and wider economic growth’.

The driving experience

But what about driving these cars? Can the motoring experience inspire consumer interest?

The answer to that is yes, according to famous petrolhead and presenter of motoring program Top Gear, James May, who has written and spoken about owning a Toyota Mirai on several occasions. 

Talking to Sky News last year, he revealed that he owned both an electric vehicle (EV) and a hydrogen car, and had been ‘comparing them in the real world’.

May said he said he is not an evangelist for either car, but has enjoyed the experience of driving both of them, which he described as ‘quiet serene and polite’.

However, May noted that while both vehicles offer eco-advantages, they also come with their own downsides.

Courtesy Hyundai

When it comes to EVs, the most notable issue is mining for raw materials for the batteries (like cobalt and nickel), which is an intensive process. Additionally, the batteries take a long time to charge, and as May has noted, there is ‘no obvious battery development on the near horizon’. 

Perhaps unsurprisingly, a key issue he cited when it comes to hydrogen cars is the lack of infrastructure required to refuel the vehicles. 

Despite these issues, groups like UKH2Mobility are forging ahead with promoting a hydrogen-powered motoring future. And according to the organization’s hydrogen mobility strategy for the early 2020s, there are myriad reasons doing so (including airplane companies).

“When used in a fuel cell vehicle there are no harmful emissions, avoiding the impact on human health associated with poor quality air,” it said.

“By 2030, hydrogen vehicles will offer an affordable option for the majority of vehicle types and their customers. 

“As a result, hydrogen vehicles will create a viable pathway to mobility with no local emissions and elimination of CO2 emissions.”

Related on Ethos:


Kim Kardashian, ‘Cool Carpool Mom,’ Gets a Cybertruck as EV Market Stumbles

Tesla gets a Kardashian bump but other EV leaders continue to swerve on the market's uneven terrain.

Lululemon Cracks the Code on Nylon Recycling As Renewcell’s Circulose Supplier Network Expands to More Than 150

Material innovations from Lululemon and Samsara Eco, along with Renewcell's expanding Circulose Supplier Network offer a glimpse into a future where fashion and environmental stewardship go hand in hand.

Verizon’s $1 Billion Green Bond Fuels Solar and Wind Projects Across 5 States

Verizon will support renewable energy in five states while a Spanish solar, wind, and battery storage provider expands in Texas.

Eco-Friendly City Planning: Reducing Our Urban Footprint

By learning from past mistakes, we can create eco-friendly cities that prioritize the well-being of both people and the environment.

How AI Sizing Helps Reduce the Carbon Footprint of Clothing Returns

Bold Metrics and Pact have announced a partnership to drive sustainability through personalized AI sizing aimed at reducing returns and their carbon footprint. Can it work?