Don Melchor’s 2021 Cabernet Sauvignon, named Wine Spectator’s No. 1 Wine of the Year, highlights Puente Alto’s old-vine heritage and Enrique Tirado’s research-led approach blending agroecology and innovation.
Chilean winemaker Don Melchor has built its reputation on precision and legacy in equal measure. That balance was affirmed when Wine Spectator named the 2021 Don Melchor Cabernet Sauvignon its No. 1 Wine of the Year for 2024. The accolade reflects not only the quality of a single vintage but also the estate’s decades-long focus on massal selection, agroecological farming, and vineyard research that now includes an experimental radial planting known as the Sundial Vineyard.
“The 2021 vintage of Don Melchor stood out because it is the purest expression of our ongoing commitment to excellence, precision, and respect for its origin,” Enrique Tirado, Don Melchor CEO and Technical Director, told Ethos via email. “What truly resonated with critics and connoisseurs was how this vintage captured the unique identity of our Puente Alto terroir — its Andean influence, alluvial soils, and remarkable thermal amplitude — delivering a Cabernet Sauvignon of exceptional finesse and energy.”
A singular Cabernet born of old-vine material and modern science
Puente Alto sits on the third alluvial terrace of the Maipo River at roughly 650 meters in the Andes foothills — stony, fast-draining soils with scarce nutrients and a strong day-night temperature swing. This matrix of ancient riverbed gravels and altitude is central to the wine’s line and longevity.
If the terroir provides the raw architecture, the winemaking sharpens its edges. Don Melchor’s final composition is built parcel by parcel, then refined with Bordeaux consultant Éric Boissenot, who succeeded his father, Jacques, in guiding the blend. The sessions take place in Lamarque in the Médoc and involve tasting hundreds of component wines to capture Puente Alto’s profile in a given year.
“The Sundial Vineyard represents a new dimension in our pursuit of excellence. It’s a living laboratory, a source of knowledge for Chilean viticulture, and a testament to how innovation and tradition can — and must — coexist when striving to craft truly exceptional wines,” Tirado says. Conceived as a working experiment, the radial “sundial” plot — planted in 2018 with the estate’s own massal selection of Cabernet Sauvignon comprises 60 spokes and 900 vines across 0.16 hectares, all on their own roots.
Designed to generate microclimates within a single block, the layout captures real-time differences in sun exposure, cluster temperature, photosynthesis, and water use. Insights from the trial are already informing management across the estate’s roughly 125 hectares and guiding the architecture of future vineyards to be more resilient, efficient, and biodiversity-friendly.
“I conceived the Sundial Vineyard as a highly precise scientific experiment. Its radial layout — an unprecedented approach in viticulture — allows us to explore how row orientation and planting density influence key factors such as solar radiation, cluster-level temperature, photosynthesis, water use efficiency, and the development of phenolic compounds essential to wine quality,” Tirado says.
Agroecology as quality control
The research agenda sits within an agroecological framework that treats the vineyard as a living network rather than a factory floor. “We believe that true wine quality begins with a healthy, balanced vineyard ecosystem,” Tirado says. “My team and I are committed to agroecological practices, such as promoting biodiversity, regenerating soils, and using efficient water management, which allows us to naturally protect our vines and enhance the unique expression of our terroir.”
On the ground, that philosophy means more than a handful of cover crop rows. “We promote the growth of diverse plant species, flowers, and cover crops between the vine rows, which help enrich the soil, prevent erosion, and support beneficial insects and natural predators,” Tirado says. “Our biological corridors and ponds provide vital habitats that encourage biodiversity and maintain ecological balance.”
Water is also managed with precision and care. Since 2003, Don Melchor has used an advanced drip irrigation system to ensure efficient water use across all vineyard parcels. “We also collect and store rainfall and enrich the soil with organic matter to improve moisture retention — ensuring vines receive the water they need while minimizing waste,” Tirado says.
Soil regeneration is another cornerstone of the label’s sustainability strategy. The use of compost, green manure, and cover crops helps to restore soil vitality and sequester carbon. These practices have allowed Don Melchor to become a carbon-neutral vineyard, capturing over 152,000 tons of CO₂e to date.
In 2004, the team conducted a meticulous selection of 3,000 plants to codify the proprietary field selection now used across the property — an example of turning heritage into a tool for future resilience. “Balancing the deep heritage of our vineyard with ongoing innovation is both a great responsibility and a source of pride,” says Tirado. “These original vines, propagated through massal selection on their own roots, preserve the authentic DNA and genetic diversity of those first French varieties.”
Climate signals, read in real time
Puente Alto is one of Maipo’s cooler zones, with an average annual temperature close to 14.4°C (58°F), winter-concentrated rainfall around one foot, and a long, dry growing season — conditions that favor slow ripening and nerve. Those baselines, documented in the estate’s recent harvest report, are not static. “While we haven’t observed drastic changes in Puente Alto so far, we have noticed that climate extremes are becoming more pronounced — hot days are hotter, and cold events can be more intense or unpredictable than in previous years.” The data provide a critical context for the vineyard’s adaptive trials.
“We are committed not only to adapting reactively, but also to anticipating future scenarios. Projects like our Sundial Vineyard are central to this strategy,” Tirado says. The radial trials and microclimate monitoring have already yielded insights that inform canopy shading, irrigation timing, and the architecture of new plantings — building a vineyard that can ride out volatility without losing identity.
How excellence is assembled
Don Melchor’s scientific posture gained momentum when it became an independent business unit under the Concha y Toro umbrella, a move announced in 2019 that ring-fenced resources for long-horizon projects and sharpened the brand’s luxury positioning.
Structural autonomy has enabled investments in vineyard-specific studies, sustainability initiatives, and precision agriculture tailored to Puente Alto, rather than competing with broader portfolio priorities. “With greater autonomy, we now have the flexibility to make decisions tailored specifically to the unique identity and aspirations of Don Melchor as a luxury wine brand,” Tirado says.
Wine Spectator framed the 2021 bottling as the culmination of a 35-vintage arc and a benchmark for Chile. The wine’s composition — Cabernet Sauvignon supported by small portions of Cabernet Franc and Merlot, aged in French oak — shows the house style at its most finely tuned. The Puente Alto vineyard is divided into seven main parcels and more than 100 micro-parcels to capture nuance, and production decisions track those divisions from harvest to blending; Tirado continues to craft the final cuvée with Boissenot.
“The wines from this vintage were incredibly expressive, brimming with concentration, and beautifully dense and long,” he says. “They truly cast a spotlight on the fruit and textural quality of every variety grown in the Don Melchor Vineyard, displaying a fine balance between finesse and energy, with extremely expressive flavors and aromas.”
Commitment that shows up in the glass
Quality and stewardship are not separate tracks at Don Melchor. “Biodiversity plays a key role in this process,” Tirado says. “By encouraging a rich variety of plants, animals, and microorganisms, we create an environment where vines thrive, pests are naturally controlled, and soil health is strengthened. These efforts not only support sustainability but also elevate the purity, complexity, and consistency of our wines.”
That logic mirrors the broader direction of Chile’s top producers, which have tied export-facing quality strategies to formal sustainability benchmarks, including a national sustainability code and, in Concha y Toro’s case, B Corp re-certification in 2024. In practice, these frameworks have meant fewer chemical interventions, more disciplined water stewardship, and soils better prepared to buffer heat spikes and cool snaps.
“What truly matters,” Tirado says, is the integration of science and place. “For us, proactive adaptation means blending tradition with innovation — honoring the character of Puente Alto, while preparing for the future with scientific precision.” And that view extends to the consumer experience. “When someone opens a bottle of Don Melchor, I hope they feel the passion behind every detail, our commitment to excellence, precision, and the deep respect we have for this extraordinary place of origin.”
Related on Ethos:
