Secondhand is moving from backup plan to main event in holiday gifting. Know exactly what to snag and what to skip so your thrifted gifts feel thoughtful, clean, and uniquely perfect.
The priciest part of the holidays is no longer the plane ticket home; it is the presents. That squeeze is exactly why resale has shifted from side hustle to main strategy for a growing number of shoppers who want gifts to feel personal without blowing their budget.
Recent data backs that up. A recent report from OfferUp finds that more than 80 percent of shoppers plan to shop secondhand this year. A report from ThredUp found that shoppers will allocate nearly 40 percent of their holiday budgets to secondhand gifts, up from about 30 percent of what they typically spend on resale the rest of the year.
“While the macroeconomic picture remains unclear, consumers aren’t stopping their holiday traditions — they’re just getting more strategic on how they participate. They’re seeking the most value, and that path is increasingly through resale,” James Reinhart, CEO and Cofounder of ThredUp, said in a statement. “This holiday season proves consumers are incredibly financially savvy. Close to half of all shoppers are turning old items into cash they can use for holiday gifts. This circular strategy is becoming a major part of how they fund their holiday spending.”
The key shift this holiday season is where exactly that money is going; it is not all luxury consignment sites and gently used designer handbags or luxury watches. The bulk of secondhand gifting happens in far less polished spaces: local charity shops, vintage boutiques, neighborhood flea markets, and Goodwill outlets where merchandise is sold by the pound. “Secondhand gifting isn’t just about saving money; it’s emotional. It allows you to find something truly unique or nostalgic that carries a story,” said Kristen Brophy, ThredUp’s senior vice president of marketing. “Consumers are finding that the best gift doesn’t have to be new, it just has to be special.”
If you are planning to build your gift list out of other people’s castoffs this year, there are some tricks to do it well, including what to hunt for, what to leave behind on the rack, and how to make those finds feel considered rather than like a last-minute panic grab.
When and where to thrift for gifts
For gifting, the most successful secondhand strategy is closer to grocery shopping than to aimless browsing. You want a loose list, a sense of timing, and a circuit of stores that match the kind of presents you want to give.
Start with the calendar. Experts suggest the best time to go thrift shopping is midweek, especially on Tuesdays and Wednesdays, when donations from busy weekends have usually been processed and moved to the floor, but the aisles are still relatively calm. Many thrift stores also designate specific restock days, and staff will often tell you if you ask. Knowing when new inventory appears can matter more than knowing the exact discount color of the week.
Chain thrift stores such as Goodwill publish sale calendars, including color-tag promotions and occasional “fill a bag” days that are especially useful if you are building a themed gift, like a stack of cookbooks or a starter kitchen kit. Frugal-shopping sites advise signing up for your local store’s email list and following its social channels so you know when those sales are coming.
Then there are the Goodwill Outlet locations, often called “the bins.” Instead of traditional racks, inventory is dumped into rolling tubs and priced by weight. Resellers who treat thrifting as a job swear by arriving at opening time and staying through several “rotations,” when staff roll old tubs away and replace them with fresh ones. Experienced bin shoppers recommend digging first and editing later: fill your cart quickly, then move to a quiet corner to inspect every item in good light.
Beyond the big-box charities, map out two or three independent thrift or church shops, plus at least one vintage or antique store for higher-quality homeware and jewelry. Vintage stores will be more expensive, but the curation can be worth it if you are short on time or shopping for someone with a specific aesthetic.
Most importantly, write a list that reflects the people you are shopping for. You are far more likely to come home with gifts you are proud to give if you are hunting specifically for a black winter coat in a size medium, a pair of brass candlesticks, a stack of vegetarian cookbooks, and a linen tablecloth than if you are simply hoping that inspiration will strike.
What to buy secondhand and how to inspect it
Once you have a plan and a cart, the real work begins. The difference between a perfect thrifted gift and an almost-good one tends to come down to condition and quality. Expert thrifters talk constantly about the discipline of inspection.
Clothing is where you are likely to buy the most, so slow down. Thrift chains and resale coaches give similar advice: start with the fabric, then look at the stitching and hardware. High-quality garments tend to use tightly woven natural fibers like cotton, linen, wool, or silk, or substantial synthetics such as nylon. Seams should be straight, with even stitches and reinforcement at stress points including pockets and armholes. Zippers should glide without snagging, and buttons should feel firmly attached rather than wobbling on loose threads.
Try to develop a habit of turning garments inside out. Run your fingers along every seam, tug gently at belt loops, and look closely at hems, cuffs, collars, and underarms. Reselling coaches remind shoppers to check collars for makeup stains, cuffs for food marks, and underarms for rings or deodorant shadows. Be sure to inspect the back of the garment too for holes and stains. It’s easy to overlook the backside of a gorgeous sweater, only to find the moths had the same idea on the other side! A little wear at a sleeve edge can be charming, but shiny seats on trousers or heavy pilling on sweaters is a reason to move on.
Fit is the other place where secondhand clothing can go wrong. Vintage sizes do not coincide with modern sizes, nor are they predictable when compared with other items from the same era, so you may even want to carry a measuring tape so you can compare garment measurements. Numbers are just a starting point; the goal is a piece that feels good on the body of the person you are gifting.
Knitwear, especially wool and cashmere, can be a standout secondhand gift if you are picky. Lay sweaters flat and look for even texture without obvious mends or tiny holes. A little pilling is fine, but heavy fuzz, thinning elbows, or misshapen ribbing suggest the sweater is at the end of its life. On the flip side, a heavy merino crewneck or a cashmere scarf with crisp edges and a soft, dense hand can feel significantly more luxurious than most mid-price new knits.
Jewelry and small accessories are some of the safest, easiest categories to buy used. Interior designers interviewed by home and interiors titles say they routinely search thrift stores for solid brass, sterling silver, and substantial costume pieces, emphasizing the importance of weight and hardware. Real brass and silver feel unexpectedly heavy; flimsy chains and hollow bangles usually signal cheap plating. Look for hallmarks such as “925” for silver and karat stamps for gold, and test clasps to make sure they close cleanly. Vintage silk scarves, leather belts, and unworn gloves can also make beautiful stocking gifts when they are in excellent condition.
Books, both for display and reading, can be excellent gifts when chosen thoughtfully. Librarians and preservation guides recommend checking that spines are not cracked, pages are firmly attached, and there is no visible mold or serious water damage. Gently fan the pages near the center to look for underlining or notes. A stack of cookbooks focused on a friend’s favorite cuisine, or a trio of vintage paperbacks with beautifully patinated covers, can feel far more intimate than the latest bestseller.
Records also make great gifts for the music lover with a home stereo system. Be sure to inspect the vinyl for deep scratches and scuffs as well as warping. Most vinyl in thrift stores is damaged, so your best bet for vinyl is a used record store, but eclectic album covers can also make for gorgeous art when popped into a frame.
Art and homewares reward a slightly different kind of attention. Prioritize pieces with good bones over trendy finishes: solid wood, real brass, glass with heft, and ceramics with smooth, even glazes. Frames and mirrors are worth a second look. “I collect mirrors, and I believe any room can benefit from having at least one mirror,” Designer Caroline Kopp told Real Simple. “Older mirrors will have interesting imperfections in the mirror surface — this is real antiqued mirror, not the fake stuff, and something that is very sought after.”
For artwork, quick checks include looking for visible brushstrokes, pencil signatures on prints, and edition numbers near the bottom edge. An original painting in a solid vintage frame can become the centerpiece of someone’s living room for the price of a new scented candle (which make fine gifts as well if you’re in a pinch!).
Finally, whatever you bring home, consider giving it a short quarantine. Better Homes and Gardens suggests dropping clothing, books, and even accessories in the freezer to kill hidden pests like moths, mites, and even bed bugs. “[M]useums and archival institutions sometimes use deep freezing techniques (often for a week or longer at very low temps) to disinfect historical documents and rare books without using harsh chemicals,” writes Lauren Bengtson.
She says to freeze books, put them in zip-lock bags, which prevents moisture from damaging the pages or cover. “Put the book in the freezer and keep it sealed for at least 48 hours, but preferably a week. When you’re ready to take it out, let it thaw slowly. Allow the book to come back to room temperature while still sealed to prevent condensation, which could cause mold or mildew.” So if you’re planning to thrift some gifts that may need a deep freeze, allow time for that process before you deliver your gift.
What to leave on the shelf
Some categories are simply too risky, from a hygiene or safety standpoint, to be worth wrapping. Top of the list are mattresses and bed pillows as well as stuffed animals. Home experts point out that these pieces accumulate skin cells, dust mites, and bodily fluids that no amount of cleaning can fully remove. The same caution extends to most upholstered furniture unless you have the budget and inclination to have it professionally cleaned and, ideally, re-covered.
Electronics are another minefield. Many thrift stores do not test items thoroughly, warranties are nonexistent, and cords or chargers may be missing. If you are shopping for someone who would genuinely enjoy a refurbished game console or a record player, it is safer to buy from a reputable refurbisher or certified secondhand electronics program rather than a random shelf.
For clothing, most experts recommend avoiding anything that has lived directly against someone else’s body in more intimate ways. Consumer advocates and stylists consistently put worn underwear, most bras, heavily used activewear, and swimsuits on the do-not-gift list unless the item is clearly new with tags.
Shoes sit somewhere in the middle. Leather boots and formal shoes that look barely worn can be brilliant secondhand finds; sneakers with deeply imprinted insoles or cracked midsoles are not. Check the tread, the interior cushioning, and the heel counter for collapse. If the shoe already looks molded to another person’s foot, it is doing its job for that person, not your gift recipient.
In homewares, skip chipped mugs and plates, nonstick pans with scratched coatings, and particle-board furniture that is already sagging. Vintage furniture experts note that particle board is prone to swelling, cannot handle weight well, and often falls apart during moves. True bargains sit elsewhere: in solid-wood side tables with dovetail joints, ceramic lamps with good wiring, and heavy glass vases that can be dressed up with fresh flowers.
Making secondhand feel luxe
Vintage and interiors experts recommend focusing on items that will age well and fit into someone’s life long term: a walnut serving board that will patinate beautifully, a brass candlestick that will mellow over time, a wool coat that will only get better with wear. Pair one star object with supporting pieces to create a story. A vintage mixing bowl becomes a baking gift when you add a wooden spoon and a handwritten recipe; a stack of thrifted novels becomes a winter reading kit with a secondhand wool blanket and a box of tea.
Packaging matters just as much as the object. Clean and, if needed, repair everything long before the holiday crunch. Swap out tarnished frames for crisp new mats, polish brass, de-pill sweaters, and remove old price stickers. Air out clothing to get rid of the secondhand store smell. A simple, uniform wrapping scheme — plain tissue, kraft paper, cloth ribbon — goes a long way toward making disparate finds feel intentional.
Perhaps most importantly, you do not need to hide the fact that something is secondhand. Many people now expect and appreciate it — surprisingly, many of those are young shoppers. “Thrifting is where you find your creativity,” Tia, a 16-year-old shopping enthusiast told Vox Atl. “It’s where you learn to put things together.”
That is the heart of a secondhand gift. You are not only saving money, but you are also editing the chaos of a crowded rack into something that feels like it could only have been chosen for the person opening it.
Related on Ethos:
