All products featured on Ethos have been independently selected by our editorial team.
When you buy something through our links, Ethos may earn an affiliate commission.
Rolex, Omega, Cartier, Vacheron Constantin, and Breitling are watches that all hold their value — but for different reasons, in different ways, and with one thing in common: nobody buys these timepieces for the reason they claim.
Nobody who buys a Rolex Daytona tells the truth about why.
This is not a criticism. It’s more of an observation about how desire works — which is that it almost never announces itself accurately. The person who buys a Daytona will tell you it holds its value, which is true. They might tell you it’s an heirloom, a thing to pass down, which is also true. What they won’t say is the thing that is most true: that they’ve wanted this watch since they saw it on the wrist of someone else, and the investment thesis came later, the way a good reason always comes after the real one.
This is fine. The rationalization happens to be correct.
According to Knight Frank’s Luxury Investment Index, luxury watches returned 125.1 percent over the last decade — second only to fine wine among alternative assets, outperforming rare whisky, classic cars, and art. The pre-owned Rolex market alone exceeds $5 billion per year, per Paul Altieri, CEO of Bob’s Watches. “We’ve never seen steel sports models run hotter than during 2020–22,” he said.
What’s interesting about the luxury watch market is that it operates on the same logic as pop stardom or art-world canonization — things are valuable because enough people have agreed they’re valuable, and that agreement has become indistinguishable from actual value. The Rolex Daytona is worth $35,000 on the secondary market for the same structural reason the Velvet Underground’s first album is worth as much as $9,000 used: the right people decided it was important, and their decision created a reality. The difference is that a Rolex keeps time and a scratched copy of The Velvet Underground & Nico mostly just makes you feel sophisticated at parties.
The luxury watch brands that retain their value
Find your next timepiece from trusted and highly sought-after brands like the following. They retain their value — whether you plan to sell yours or want to wear it for the foreseeable future.
Rolex
The Rolex Daytona has appreciated 358 percent since 2014. The Submariner, 249 percent over the same period. The Daytona Ref. 116500LN retails for $14,800 and regularly trades between $30,000 and $35,000. Per WatchCharts market data, Rolex accounted for 34.2 percent of global secondary market trade volume between 2020 and 2024.
What Rolex has built is a scarcity model so elegant it appears to be an accident. The allocation system, the waitlists, the authorized dealer relationships that determine who gets access and when — none of it is accidental, and all of it creates premiums that the brand benefits from without being directly responsible for. Altieri has noted that collectors want a good ‘honest’ watch at a good price — and by honest, that means all original with good provenance. Box and papers on a Submariner add 15 to 30 percent to resale.
Omega
Omega’s investment case is complicated in ways that are worth understanding. In-production Omega watches trade about 38 percent below retail on average, per WatchCharts. The Speedmaster Professional is the exception — the one NASA flew to the moon in 1969, still certified now, whose limited editions (Silver Snoopy, Apollo anniversaries) have historically appreciated well above retail. What Omega offers is genuine historical credibility at a price point that doesn’t require knowing someone’s cousin at an authorized dealer. For buyers who find the Rolex allocation system philosophically objectionable, this matters.
Cartier
Cartier’s Tank and Santos have been continuously desirable since 1917, which is the kind of track record that makes the investment case almost too simple to state. The brand has not meaningfully changed what it makes or who it makes it for in over a century. That kind of cultural legibility — recognizable without being trendy, prestigious without being aggressive about it — translates into secondary market stability. Cartier watches don’t spike. They also don’t collapse. For collectors who want steady appreciation rather than the grey market lottery, that reliability is the entire value proposition.
Vacheron Constantin
Vacheron Constantin, part of watchmaking’s Holy Trinity alongside Patek Philippe and Audemars Piguet, produces in numbers low enough that inaccessibility itself becomes the investment thesis. The Overseas and Patrimony lines are not watches found in open stock. That scarcity compounds over years in ways that reward patience over opportunism.
Breitling
Breitling — the Navitimer in particular — is the pragmatist’s choice. Functional, engineered for aviators, not interested in being mistaken for something it isn’t. The secondary market is stable rather than spectacular, which is actually what most people mean when they reach for the word “investment.” They mean they don’t want to lose money. Breitling generally delivers on that, without requiring anyone to believe in anything.
All of which returns to the original problem: nobody who buys one of these watches is being entirely honest about why. The investment case is real, but it arrived after the desire, not before it. That’s not a knock on the watch. If anything, it’s a point in its favor. It is a rare and fortunate thing when what you wanted all along turns out to have been the smart move.
Related on Ethos:
